Do eco tyres really save you money?

Do eco tyres really save you money?

Preliminary tests have shown that ratings on tyre labels are not telling the full story. At mid-range speeds, an F-rated tyre performs as well as a B-rated tyre for fuel economy.

 

We tested two contrasting sets of 175/70 R14 tyres on the road. One set was a standard tyre with B-rating for fuel economy and the other had an F-rating. The test route incorporated a range of steady-state speeds from 40mph to 70mph on tarmac in consistent ambient temperatures.

You can see from this graph that the B rated tyre was superior in the 40-70 mph range by an average of 3.8% mpg and 3.4% less CO2. There isn’t much in it at the mid-range speed but a performance gap opens up at 55mph and by the time you get to 70mph the fuel economy has improved by 12.9%.

Do eco tyres really save you money?

Thus a consumer buying B rated tyres is unlikely to notice a fuel economy benefit if the journeys they customarily make are mainly urban. Whereas a consumer heading up and down the motorway each day should enjoy an improvement.

Now this was an unashamedly quick and dirty investigation but it does demonstrate that the relationship between rolling resistance and fuel economy is not linear and that to bring real improvements to the way tyres are bought and sold manufacturers need to adopt more sophisticated models.

The current tyre labelling system, made mandatory by the EU in November 2012, is not working. In a report compiled by the National Tyre Distributors Association (NTDA) and LANXESS, the manufacturers of high-tech rubber for tyres, it was found that one year on 93% of tyre retailers said customers never or only occasionally requested information on the label and only 30% knew that tyres affect fuel consumption.

We think manufacturers need better models to translate rolling resistance calculations into fuel economy effects. Improved, independently verified testing and labelling, perhaps with a monetary quantification of the typical benefit would provide a tangible benefit that the consumer would welcome.

     

   Related items


  • Swedish retreader adds Marangoni technology
    Italy—Swedish retreader Dacknor A.B. has partnered with Marangoni Retreading Systems to upgrade its offerings, according to a release issued by Roverto-based... Read more
  • Disreputable traders, illegal tyres – association shares part-worn experiences
    Although the National Tyre Distributors’ Association would like to see them banned and TyreSafe implores motorists not to buy these products, around 4.5 million part-worn tyres are sold in the UK each year. The Local Government Association (LGA) has now also highlighted some of its members’ experiences with the sellers of used tyres, and cautions motorists to exercise caution when... Read more
  • Sri Lanka’s largest fully integrated tire plant to be built with Rs11.25bn
    Rigid Tyre Corporation (Pvt.) Ltd. Equipped with the latest technology, this new plant is destined to roll in a new page in the industrial sector of Sri Lanka. It comes with the healthy integration of political acumen, local entrepreneurship and proven European technology in the form of a world reputation – Marangoni of... Read more
  • ATG’s Constellation truck tyre brand not coming to Europe, for now
    Shortly after its acquisition by Yogesh Mahansaria and private equity company Warburg Pincus in 2007, the Alliance Tire Group (ATG) exited the car and truck tyre market and began building up a strong reputation as an off-road tyre... Read more
  • Michelin Unveils New UHP Tire at NAIAS
    Michelin introduced its newest ultra-high-performance tire – the MICHELIN Pilot® Sport 4 S – today at the North American International Auto Show. The product succeeds the MICHELIN® Pilot® Super Sport, which is widely recognized as the industry-leading ultra-high-performance tire for original equipment and replacement... Read more
Comments
Login to post comments

MOD_LOGINREGISTER_LOGIN_TITLE

Remember Me